When I process a cube with the HOLAP (100% performance gain) storage option the querytime from Excel XP is very fast.
When I process the same cube with the MOLAP (100% performance gain) storage option the same query takes forever.
I'm puzzled. Can someone explain this?
Edwin
P.S. THe cube has a DistinctCount measure in it. Does this have anything to do with the poor MOLAP performance?You are correct - that is unusual. How big are both of the cubes ? Have you tried duplicating the same behavior with the foodmart sample ? Since you are suspicious of the distinctcount - have you eliminated that measure to see how it affects performance ?|||Have you tried it under excel 2000 ?|||Thank for the reply.
Excel 2000 gives me the same problem, as well as the cube data browser in the Analysis Manager itself.
I replaced the Distinct Count by a Sum. Performance was OK in both HOLAP and MOLAP, so the Distinct Count causes the pain (but I really need it).
I couldn't reproduce the same thing in the Foodmart cubes (size perhaps?).
Maybe I stumbled on some undocumented limit.
Another thing: In HOLAP mode with 100% performance gain it still computes aggregation data in Oracle. I know this, because when I shut Oracle I get #value errors. I thougt 100% means 'all aggregations in Analysis Services'. Also I'm often exactly 1 above the exact value with the Distinct Counts, because NULL seams to count a distinct value.
I rfead somewhere that Analysis Services transform a NULL into a 0 when one of the other measures in the source table is not NULL.
Is that correct, and if so, is there a patch for that? Otherwise I must define fact-views for each Distinct Count measure with "WHERE ... IS NOT NULL".
Development Server : PIII 500, 512 MB memory
(should eat this 7.5MB cube for breakfast)
Relational database: Oracle 8.1.7.3
Analysis Services : Service Pack 2
Fact table: : 69000 rows
Measures: : 1 Distinct Count
Dimension data : 1 3000 members, 1 level
2 69000 members, divided in 7 levels
3 Price-dimension (hierarchy 1)
4 Price-dimension (hierarchy 2)
Cube in MB 7.5 MB (in both HOLAP and MOLAP mode)
Edwin
Showing posts with label storage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label storage. Show all posts
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)